A specialist ecosystem has grown up around each of the four risks in an S/4HANA programme. SAP’s own SAP Signavio and the process-mining company Celonis make today’s processes visible before anyone designs tomorrow’s. smartShift analyses and automatically remediates custom ABAP code. Natuvion, like SNP in Part 1 of this series, moves data selectively, rehearses the cutover and retires what’s left.
None of them replaces the system integrator, and none is free. Used in the right phase with the right owner, they turn guesses into measurements. Used as slides in a proposal, they add cost and a false sense of safety.
The roadmap
The bars show where each tool does its main work across SAP Activate’s six phases. Most of the value comes from starting early: the process baseline and the code and data scans belong in Discover and Prepare, before scope and price are fixed.
Phase placement combines SAP Activate guidance, vendor material and our judgement where vendors don’t state a phase. Most programmes need one primary process-mining tool, not two.
What each tool brings
| Tool | De-risks | Evidence |
|---|---|---|
| SAP Signavio | Process discovery and design inside the SAP toolchain; models sync to SAP Cloud ALM. A starter pack, including one Process Insights data load, comes with RISE with SAP. | SAP product; Joule with SAP Signavio generally available in 2026 |
| Celonis | Deep, object-centric process baselines across SAP and non-SAP; test variants; post go-live conformance. | HARMAN found 34% of custom transaction codes rarely usedVendor-reported |
| smartShift | Custom-code analysis and automated remediation; dual maintenance shortens the code freeze; clean-core and ABAP Cloud enablement. | Jabil: ~5M lines in 5 weeks; Forrester TEI (commissioned) 253% ROIVendor-reported |
| Natuvion | Selective data transition, anonymised test data, rehearsed cutover, legacy retirement. | BMW: 30+ TB, ≤72h downtime; Wiener Linien: 54h vs 72h plannedVendor-reported |
Signavio or Celonis?
Choose SAP Signavio if you are on RISE with SAP, your landscape is mostly SAP and you want process models to flow into Cloud ALM and LeanIX with little integration work. Choose Celonis if many non-SAP systems sit in your end-to-end processes, you already run a Celonis centre of excellence, or you need object-centric analysis and action automation. One caution: Celonis is in litigation with SAP over access to SAP data. SAP has agreed not to interfere with Celonis’s extractor while the US case continues, so write the extraction route and any licence implications into the contract.
The value case in four levers
- Less scope: retire unused transactions, code and data instead of migrating them.
- Less effort: automated remediation and repeatable migration runs replace manual work.
- Less disruption: a shorter code freeze and a shorter cutover window.
- More value: the same process KPIs measured before and after go-live.
Where integration with SAP isn’t stated, the integrator owns the gap: who moves partner-tool results into Cloud ALM, the test plan and the cutover runbook. Put it in the plan and the price, or the programme will do it unpaid in month nine.
The whitepaper covers each tool in depth, an integration matrix against eight SAP components, the business-case metrics, five ways partner tools fail to pay back, and ten questions for bid teams and buyers.
The Partner Toolchain: A Roadmap for De-risking SAP S/4HANA
13 pages, with the full roadmap and 50 sources. No sign-up, no email required.
Building a toolchain into a bid, or evaluating one? Our Orange Team review stress-tests the licences, scope lines and responsibility seams between integrator and partners, and our buy-side support helps you question each bidder’s toolchain. Book a free discovery call.
Independence: Dealcraft Advisory has no commercial relationship with SAP, Celonis, smartShift, Natuvion or SNP, and none of them commissioned or reviewed this article. Customer outcomes are as reported by the vendors. The litigation summary is general information, not legal advice. SAP, S/4HANA, RISE with SAP, SAP Signavio and SAP LeanIX are trademarks of SAP SE; other names belong to their owners.