For SAP customers the clock is visible: mainstream maintenance for ECC ends at the end of 2027, with optional extended maintenance to 2030 at extra cost, as SAP announced. Gartner estimated in early 2025 that over 60% of SAP customers were still on ECC with no decision yet to move. For Oracle, Microsoft and other ERP users the deadlines differ, but the decision is the same.
And it is a decision that is usually made too late, or by default. A supplier proposes the approach that suits its strengths, the business case is built around it, and only months later does anyone ask whether it was the right path at all.
Three paths, one question
Greenfield means starting again on a new system, designed largely on standard processes, and moving only the data you need. It brings the most change and the cleanest result.
Brownfield means converting your existing system: configuration, custom code, processes and full history come across. It brings the least change on day one, and the risk of carrying yesterday's technical debt into tomorrow's platform.
Bluefield, more formally selective data transition, sits in between. You keep what still works, rebuild what doesn't, and choose which entities, processes and years of history come across. It suits organisations consolidating several systems, or with a mix of good and poor processes, and it depends on specialist tools and people.
No path is right for everyone. Surveys agree on that much: ASUG found 34% of its members choosing brownfield, 33% greenfield and 20% hybrid in 2024, while ISG's 2026 study of 200 large organisations found 34% brownfield, 18% greenfield and nearly half mixing the two.
Why the path comes before the vendor
For the CFO, the path decides the cost curve, when value arrives and where the risk sits. Greenfield spends most upfront on design, change and data. Brownfield is often cheapest to go live but usually needs a second, later spend to improve the processes it carried over. Bluefield's cost depends heavily on how much you select.
For business owners, it decides how different Monday morning will feel after go-live, and how much of their best people's time the programme will need before it.
For procurement, it decides what you are actually buying. If the path isn't settled before you go to market, you end up comparing prices for different things, and holding suppliers to a scope nobody fully defined.
The evidence says plan for the range
ISG found that only 15% of the SAP migrations it studied were on time and on budget, and 58% were both late and over budget. Horváth's survey of 200 SAP users found projects took 30% longer than planned on average. ISG's conclusion is the useful one: delays are most often caused by weak governance rather than technical challenges. Many of those governance choices are made the moment you choose your path.
Five questions to start with
- Do your core processes still fit how the business wants to work? Mostly yes points to brownfield, mostly no to greenfield, a mix to bluefield.
- How much of your custom code is actually used? Measure it before you decide. Unused code is expensive to convert and cheap to leave behind.
- How good is your data? Poor data argues for a fresh start, with clean-up done before migration, not during it.
- How much history must stay live? Whatever you don't migrate must still be retained and auditable. Irish Revenue generally requires six years.
- How much change can the organisation absorb in the next two to three years? Match the path to that, not to the change you'd like to achieve.
Download the whitepaper
Our free 12-page whitepaper sets out the three paths side by side, what each means for the CFO, business owners and procurement, ten questions that point to the right path, the traps on each one, a 90-day plan before you go to market and a 12-question checklist to take into contract negotiation. Every statistic is sourced.
Starting Your ERP Journey: Greenfield, Bluefield or Brownfield?
12 pages. No sign-up, no email required.
Starting an ERP procurement? Our buy-side tender support helps you settle the path, define the requirement and run a tender every supplier prices the same way. Book a free discovery call or email sales@dealcraftadvisory.ie.